The grossly misunderstood banality of evil theory israel. Eichmann, the banality of evil, and thinking in arendts. As i read, the controversial nature of arendt s book was brought home to me. Although hannah arendt is often described as a radical thinker, this.
Hannah arendt and the final solution kindle edition by bergen, bernard j download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Fifty years ago, the new yorker published a series of articles that became one of the most controversial books of the 20th century. We were asked to post this response unedited by patchen markell. Her thesis is that the great evils in history generally, and the holocaust in particular, were not executed by fanatics or sociopaths, but by ordinary people who accepted the premises of their state and. A report on the banality of evil 1963 caused huge controversy on its release.
Furthermore, eichmann said that he actually had no real ill will toward jews. In any case, arendt was ostracized by the jewish community for the rest. Arendt s banality of evil thesis and the arabisraeli conflict yaron ezrahi judaism and cosmopolitanism liberating the pariah. This was the revolutionary and, like every revolutionary idea, at the time controversial point that hannah arendt october 14, 1906december 4, 1975 made in 1962, when the new yorker commissioned her, a jew of who had narrowly escaped from nazi germany herself, to travel to jerusalem and report on the trial of adolf eichmann one of the. A report on the banality of evil public library a sobering reflection on the lesson that this long course in human wickedness had taught us the lesson of the fearsome, wordandthoughtdefying banality of evil. Hannah arendts original articles on the banality of evil. The book was a report, as well as a piece of political commentary, on the trial of adolf eichmann.
The banality of evil thesis is the notion that ordinary people commit barbaric acts without realisation of what they are doing. The hannah arendt papers the library of congress manuscript division. Arendt, a jew who fled germany during adolf hitlers rise to power, reported on adolf eichmanns trial for the new yorker. One of the preeminent political thinkers of the 20th century, arendt, who died in 1975 at the age of 69, was a. Arendt, hannah internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Hannah arendt and the glorification of thinking the new.
First we provide a brief account of how arendt came to write eichmann in jerusalem and explain her central arguments and observations. Hannah arendt s last essay on bertolt brecht, written after his death, is remarkable for its affective. If something is banal, it is common, boring and unoriginal. Yale professor seyla benhabib responded in a new york times piece, others blogged, and wolin responded in an essay on our website. Sep 22, 2006 a conference at yale university honoring the influential writer and political philosopher hannah arendt will take place september 29 and 30 at the whitney humanities center, 53 wall st. The young hannah arendt had written her doctoral dissertation under the great german philosopher karl jaspers, and the topic of her work was the concept of love in the writings of st. Hannah arendt discussed the banality of evil in her book about nazi war criminal adolf eichmann. Hannah arendts political theory is often understood to rest on a celebration of action, the memorable words and deeds of named individuals. In his book bound by recognition patchen markell, inspired by arendt. See all articles by patchen markell patchen markell. Hannah arendt famously propagated the banality of evil. A book would be required to report how the banality of evil has become banal over the decades since hannah arendt published her controversial eichmann in jerusalem 1963. A conference at yale university honoring the influential writer and political philosopher hannah arendt will take place september 29 and 30 at the whitney humanities center, 53 wall st titled hannah arendt at one hundred. I had long wanted to read hannah arendts 1906 1975 study of the eichmann trial, eichmann in jerusalem.
Hannah arendt is one of the most important political theorists of the 20th century. Instead of giving small gestures and daily labors grand scope, hannah arendtwhich stars. I have been asked to address the question is evil banal. A report on the banality of evil, her book on the trial of nazi lieutenantcolonel adolf eichmann. Hannah arendt revisits fiery debate over germanamerican theorists. Aug 19, 2011 the capacity for evil can spread like an epidemic. Watch hannah arendts diagnosis of the banality of evil as.
The capacity for evil can spread like an epidemic elisabeth. In her treatise on the banality of evil, arendt demanded a rethink of established ideas about moral responsibility mon 29 aug 2011 07. A report on the banality of evil abstract in this essay, we offer a modern legal reading of hannah arendts classic book, eichmann in jerusalem. A report on the banality of evil is a 1963 book by political theorist hannah arendt. Cannot hannah arendts banality of evil be subject to transposition.
And so what is meant as a frivolous and banal joke is permitted to take on. Patchen markell department of government cornell arts. Hannah arendt was born johanna cohn arendt in 1906 into a comfortable educated secular family of german jews in linden, prussia now a part of hanover, in wilhelmine germany. A report on the banality of evil and was prompted at last to do so when i found the book on sale at my local library.
Hannah arendt and the final solution by bergen, bernard j. The promise or reconciliation, which is neither forgetfulness nor an averted glance, but a fullbodied recognition of the human condition, is that it preserves the possibility of love in the case of hannah arendt and martin heidegger, an easy commerce between old friends and friendship, as hannah understood, is the foundation of all. Sep 24, 20 evil can never truly be beautiful, for beauty is a property of being. Nor, on reflection, do i think that the facts of hannah arendts personal history. Apr 23, 2018 arendt dubbed these collective characteristics of eichmann the banality of evil. Blog entry, hannah arendt center for politics and the humanities november 7, 2011. In her works, she grappled with the dark events of that century, probing the. Hannah arendt on civil disobedience and constitutional patriotism verity smith promising and civil disobedience. This was the puzzling question that the philosopher hannah arendt grappled with when she reported for the new yorker in 1961 on the. This highly original book is the first to explore the political and philosophical consequences of hannah arendts concept of the banality of evil, a term she used to describe adolph eichmann, architect of the nazi final solution.
Eichmann, the banality of evil, and thinking in arendts thought. Many have delighted in judging hannah arendt, maybe because they have. About thoughtlessness however, it is clear from arendts report of eichmann that he had knowledge, and that he was able to. Arendts grandparents were members of the reform jewish community there.
History of political theory lectures, the hannah arendt papers at the library of congress, washington. Oct 14, 2014 i find it astounding that in the course of the by now rather extensive exchange between seyla benhabib and richard wolin regarding hannah arendt s phrase the banality of evil, that which more than anything else can help us understand that phrase and give it a most painful reality is never mentioned even once by either author. Much of arendt s thought, maeirkatkin argues, can be understood as a development of her reflections upon heidegger and how a person of his great gifts could embrace a shockingly repugnant ideology. The interview ranged across a wide field of topics, including the difference. One of the most significant intellectual breakthroughs of augustines life was the insight that evil is not something substantial, but rather a type.
To arendts mind, eichmann willingly did his part to organize the holocaust and an instrumental part it was out of neither anti. Hannah arendt famously propagated the banality of evil but. This book originates in an unusual conference that was held at bard college to celebrate hannah arendts onehundredth birthday. Patchen markell has argued that arendt also throws into question certain boundaries of. Hannah arendt argued that adolf eichmann was just an ordinary guy. Her banality of evil, in my interpretation, refers to the idea that evil can be normalized in situations where generally accepted morality is massively altered, like during the holocaust. We were asked to post this response unedited by patchen markell, who does not have.
Studies in contemporary jewry bernard bergen has written a thoughtful, clear inquiry into the key concepts and interpretations that make up hannah arendt s theory of totalitarianism. When eichmann was taken captive in argentina by agents of the israeli government and brought to trial in jerusalem, arendt saw an opportunity, unusual for philosophers, to confront the realm of human affairs and human deeds. The articles dealt with the trial of adolf eichmann, the nazi ss officer who coordinated the logistics of transporting millions of european jews to their death during world. Anonymous glory patchen markell, 2017 sage journals. This year is the new yorker s eightyfifth anniversary. Hannah arendt is one of the most important political theorists of the twentieth century. We publish history, politics, current affairs, art. For many critics, it is impossible to reconcile the deeds of nazi operative. A revised and enlarged edition was published in 1964. Arendt surely condemned his actions on a personal level and found them deplorable. The movie hannah arendt, which opened in new york in may, has unleashed emotional commentary that mirrors the fierce debate arendt herself ignited over half a century ago, when she covered the trial of the notorious war criminal adolf eichmann. I had long wanted to read hannah arendt s 1906 1975 study of the eichmann trial, eichmann in jerusalem.
Her family were merchants of russian extraction from konigsberg, the east prussian capital. Misreading eichmann in jerusalem the new york times. Arendt reflected upon the nature of evil its commonplace, everyday character, which she famously came to call its banality. Arendt dubbed these collective characteristics of eichmann the banality of evil. The trial of hannah arendt national endowment for the. May 30, 20 hannah arendt, unfortunately, doesnt do its title character justice. This highly original book is the first to explore the political and philosophical consequences of hannah arendt s concept of the banality of evil, a term she used to describe adolph eichmann, architect of the nazi final solution.
Hannah arendt was a humanist thinker who thought boldly and provocatively about our shared political and ethical world. Hannah arendt quotes author of eichmann in jerusalem. Hannah arendt most memorably employed it in both the subtitle and closing words of eichmann in jerusalem. An exchange of letters between gershom sholem and hannah arendt, encounter 22 january 1964. Banality of evil is a phrase coined by hannah arendt in the title of her 1963 work eichmann in jerusalem. That this can be true and eichmann had a very personal interest in the genocide of the jewish people was most recently demonstrated by a very elaborated biography which focuses mainly on this point. Which hannah arendt tried to put in one phrase is the picture of a man who is a normal family man and an acurate worker. Conference at yale honors hannah arendt at 100 yalenews. With thomas wild and ursula ludz, i am one of the coeditors of the volume devoted to arendt. Hannah arendt and the glorification of thinking the.
The movie, unfortunately, doesnt do arendt justice. I am currently finishing a book on hannah arendts political thought called politics against rule. Anyone who reads hannah arendts writings which offer numerous insights about the banality of evil, even when she doesnt use the term directly cannot take seriously the propositions ascribed to her by sociologist eva illouz. Arendt wanted to find out more about the mind of this man, who had committed such terrible. Arendt used the words the banality of evil to describe what she saw in eichmann. Whitfield brandeis university two decades ago israeli agents captured adolf eichmann in argentina. Instead, her thoughts span totalitarianism, revolution, the nature of freedom and the faculties of thought and.
He refused the help of the protestant minister the reverend william hull who offered to read the bible with him. He had asked for a bottle of red wine and had drunk half of it. Jul 07, 20 the movie hannah arendt, which opened in new york in may, has unleashed emotional commentary that mirrors the fierce debate arendt herself ignited over half a century ago, when she covered the trial of the notorious war criminal adolf eichmann. A report on the banality of evil the holocaust was a genocide in which some six million european jews were killed by adolf hitlers nazi germany, and the world war ii collaborators with. The house of justice beth hamishpath the house of justice. But this is certainly not what arendt meant when she concluded that the trial had been a long course in human wickedness that had taught us the lesson of the fearsome, wordandthoughtdefying banality of. What did hannah arendt really mean by the banality of evil. Hannah arendt famously spoke of the banality of evil.
Having spent five years delving into the writings of the political thinker hannah arendt, while researching my 2015 documentary vita activa. Eichmann, the banality of evil, and thinking in arendts thought bethania assy. The philosophy of hannah arendt, 20142015 prospectus. Aug 29, 2011 f ifty years ago the writer and philosopher hannah arendt witnessed the end of the trial of adolf eichmann, one of the major figures in the organisation of the holocaust. Western political science association 2010 annual meeting paper. By patchen markellto read this line from the human condition in the wake of the demonstrations in tahrir square, or in the midst of the occupations that have radiated from zuccotti park across the united states and beyond, might be invigorating. In 1963, her writings about the trial were published as eichmann in jerusalem. The experience of action patchen markell dissent in dark times. Bergen, the questions that preoccupied arendt were the meaning and significance of the nazi genocide to our modern.
Arendt on the foundations of equality jeremy waldron. I analyze the ways in which the faculty of thinking can avoid evil action, taking into account hannah arendts discussion regarding the banality of evil and thoughtlessness in connection with the eichmann trial. Instead, her thoughts span totalitarianism, revolution, the nature of freedom and the. Hannah arendt 19061975 hannah arendt is a twentieth century political philosopher whose writings do not easily come together into a systematic philosophy that expounds and expands upon a single argument over a sequence of works. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the banality of evil. The official blog of yale university press, london. As sick as it is, the nazi party did not see their ideals as evil. Hannah arendts political phenomenology of world borren, m. Apr 30, 2018 ideas in literature hannah arendt famously spoke of the banality of evil. Hannah arendt and the study of evil philosopher hannah arendt spent her life examining the totalitarian states of the 20th century, coining the phrase banality of evil. The spirit of hannah arendt, i take the liberty of stating that israeli sociologist eva illouz, in her article rethinking the banality of evil theory haaretz, august 5, displays an unfortunate miscomprehension of that fraught term. To celebrate, over eightyfive weekdays we will turn a spotlight on a notable article, story, or poem from the magazines history. Arendt did not elaborate on what she meant by the phrase but readers can understand what she meant due to hints throughout the book.
Adolf eichmann went to the gallows with great dignity. The great moral lesson articulated by both augustine and hannah arendt is that we must refuse to be beguiled by the glittering banality of wickedness and we must consistently choose the substance over the shadow. Hannah arendts challenge to adolf eichmann judith butler. Instead of giving small gestures and daily labors grand scope, the film. Hannah arendt is a twentieth century political philosopher whose writings do not easily come together into a systematic philosophy that expounds and expands upon a single argument over a sequence of works. The result, i have to say, was a pretty banal discussion, for jongens own. A report on the banality of evil, her controversial analysis of the jerusalem trial of adolf eichmann, had just been published in german in the federal republic and gaus used the occasion to generate a portrait of hannah arendt. Many theorists treat democracy as one type of regime. His trial opened in jerusalem in april, 1961, lasted fourteen weeks and resulted in his conviction for crimes against the jewish people, crimes against humanity, war crimes and membership in crimi. This article presents a novel critical account of a key concept in democratic theory, rule, via an unorthodox interpretation of hannah arendt s work. People speak a lot today about the banality of evil, but not all evil is banal. This article presents a novel critical account of a key concept in democratic theory, rule, via an unorthodox interpretation of hannah arendts work. Crises of our republics, the conference gathers international scholars and writers to commemorate the centenary of.
1210 1395 584 464 763 1415 1098 941 113 1161 182 124 1028 368 917 1207 1329 305 1208 386 903 1334 929 596 926 1271 173 694 874 1013 1112 649 177 956 1484